Posted by
Tomás Aquinas on Sunday, October 11, 2009 7:34:13 PM
We've changed one of the quotes up in the Blog Banner. We've added a good one from de Tocqueville.
It
can be said that there are four documents, or publications, with which
every American must be familiar in order to understand how our country
came to be and its foundational concepts and principles.
These are:
- The Declaration of Independence
- The Constitution of the United States of America
- The Federalist Papers
- Democracy in America
That
last was written by a French nobleman, one Alexis de Tocqueville, on a
visit to this country back during the rise of Jacksonian Democracy.
I
have been re-reading Tocqueville's work, and am finding that in many
cases he was and still is amazingly astute, insightful, and accurate.
I
like the edition that I have, even though it is paperback and
well-worn. It has a good introduction, by Richard D. Heffner, and
points out some of the weaknesses of Tocqueville's observations as well
as his strengths. This is good, because as with any literary work,
especially those of subjective nature, external balance is often
necessary and useful.
In any case, I came across this passage the other day:
Force
is never more than a transient element of success, and after force,
comes the notion of right. A government which should be able to reach
its enemies only upon a field of battle would soon be destroyed.
General McChrystal's
philosophies on the conduct of war
seem far more consistent with Tocqueville's view than with ... oh ...
say the likes of Joe Biden and his desire to do it all by remote
control.
In Vietnam, it was Westmoreland's 'war of attrition',
with it's increasingly unrestricted use of increasingly heavier
weaponry that drove the Vietnamese peasant out of the villages and into
the slums of Saigon and other cities. 'We had to destroy the village in
order to save it' was a concept that drove the Vietnamese peasant into
the arms of the Viet Cong.
McChrystal seems intent on not making those mistakes again.
I
can only wonder if Obama deserves such a commander in the field ... or
will McChrystal end up under the Obama Express like so many others.